BELKACEM v BELGIUM

Application Number 34367/14 European Court of Human Rights [Judgment delivered in French] The applicant was the leader and spokesperson of the organization “Sharia4Belgium,” which was dissolved in 2012, for incitement to discrimination, hatred and violence for remarks he made in YouTube videos concerning non-Muslim groups and Sharia. The ECtHR found that his statements promoted hatred […]

FERET v BELGIUM

Application Number: 15615/07 European Court of Human Rights [Judgment delivered in French] The Chairman of Belgium’s National Front, claimed a violation of his rights under Article 10 in relation to his conviction of incitement to racism. This case dealt with anti-immigrant statements and recommendations made by Féret in leaflets distributed during an electoral campaign. Statements […]

E.S v AUSTRIA

Application Number 23131/03 European Court of Human Rights During two seminars, the applicant, a public speaker, made comments regarding the Prophet Muhammad, including that he was a pedophile. She was convicted of disparaging religious doctrines and ordered to pay a fine. The ECtHR found no violation of Article 10. Link: https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-187188%22]} Theme(s): Religious Hatred Date: […]

VEJDELAND AND OTHERS v SWEDEN

Application Number 1813/07 European Court of Human Rights The applicants gave out leaflets at a secondary school with homophobic statements, including linking HIV and AIDS and pedophilia with homosexuals. They were fined in Sweden. The ECtHR found no violation of Article 10 since their speech amounted to an attack against homosexuals, regardless of the lack […]

BEIZARAS AND LEVICKAS v. LITHUANIA

Application Number 41288/15 European Court of Human Rights Two men posted a public photograph of themselves kissing on Facebook. The post went viral. It attracted around 800 comments, most of which were hateful. The national authorities did not proceed with charging the users making hateful comments, on the grounds that the couple’s ‘eccentric behaviour’ was […]

LILLIENDAHL v ICELAND

Application Number 29297/18 European Court of Human Rights A municipal council in Iceland approved a proposal to strengthen education and counselling in schools concerning those who identify themselves as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender.  The decision was reported in the news and led to substantial public discussion, inter alia, on the radio station Ú.S. The applicant wrote comments […]

WITZSCH v GERMANY

Application Number 7485/03 European Commission of Human Rights The applicant sent a letter to a professor following an article the latter published regarding the culpability of the Nazi Party and the intention of Hitler to murder the Jews. The applicant wrote a letter to him saying that these statements were false and was subsequently convicted […]